Anatomy of a Naval Disaster: The 1746 French Naval by James Pritchard

By James Pritchard

This can be an account of 1 of the main formidable and catastrophic French naval expeditions within the 18th century, leading to the deaths of as much as 8000 males. It exposes the pursuits and frailties of guys, the arbitrariness of luck, and the boundaries of energy within the 18th century. meant as a riposte to the Anglo-American catch of Loisbourg in 1745, the so-called d'Enville day trip set out from France the subsequent 12 months to safe Canada, recapture Acadia and Louisbourg, and ravage the recent England coast as a ways south as Boston. a few of the sixty four French vessels concerned didn't go back and estimates of the lifeless reached as excessive as 8000, but the enemy was once by no means met in conflict. James Pritchard's account of this naval fiasco sheds new gentle at the quantity of the tragedy and increases questions about the position and effectiveness of naval energy throughout the intercolonial wars of the mid-18th century. Pritchard describes the household and overseas political conditions in France that gave upward push to the day trip, outlining process and politics within the context of colonial defence and continental ambition. He reconstructs the occasions that contributed to the failure of the excursion: human and institutional weak point, climate, spoiled provisions, illness and the dying of the commanding admiral.

Show description

Read Online or Download Anatomy of a Naval Disaster: The 1746 French Naval Expedition to North America PDF

Best naval books

Naval Power and Expeditionary Wars: Peripheral Campaigns and New Theatres of Naval Warfare

This e-book examines the character and personality of naval expeditionary struggle, specifically in peripheral campaigns, and the contribution of such campaigns to the success of strategic victory. Naval powers, that may lack the big floor forces to win basically theatre, usually pick out a secondary theatre obtainable to them by way of sea and tough for his or her enemies to arrive through land, giving the ocean energy and its expeditionary forces the virtue.


From the guy defined by way of Amanda Foreman as 'one of the main eminent naval historians of our age' comes the tale of ways this country's maritime strength helped Britain achieve remarkable dominance of the world's economic system. informed in the course of the lives of ten of our such a lot striking admirals, Andrew Lambert's booklet spans Elizabethan occasions to the second one international conflict, culminating with the spirit which led Andrew Browne Cunningham famously to claim, while the military feared he may lose too many ships, 'it takes 3 years to construct a boat; it takes 3 centuries to construct a tradition'.

Extra info for Anatomy of a Naval Disaster: The 1746 French Naval Expedition to North America

Example text

Canada would be secured, Louisbourg recaptured, Acadia retaken, and the coast of New England ravaged as far south as Boston, perhaps further. But now, all the bright hopes of spring lay in ruins. Not a single French military objective had been achieved. Thousands of soldiers and sailors were dead, and the final agonies remained to be endured. During the next two weeks, singly and in small groups, the remnants of the shattered fleet reached France bearing their forlorn cargoes of sick and dying men.

39 The way a story is told profoundly affects its impact. Whether the story of failure is told in a romantic glow that makes it glorious, or in the passive voice, which renders it dismal, or obliquely, which may reduce it to the status of cheap farce, the story is still the thing. My first aim, then, has been to tell a story. Even so, the techniques of several social sciences have conferred benefits on historians that cannot be dispensed with. The rigorous methods of demographers call attention to the need for great care using sources but also to the possibilities of forming links between different ones.

22 With such an interpretation and emphasis on the need for an infusion of will, there was really no need to examine the state of naval logistics, organization, and administration, to study the behaviour of individuals, or to assess the impact of domestic politics on naval affairs. This vision has largely dominated twentieth-century historiography, though a certain ambiguity remains over how such a disaster could occur during the administration of an active and enlightened naval minister. 23 But no one went beyond these conclusions.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.38 of 5 – based on 5 votes